A recreation of the world’s first neuroimaging experiment – LIVE!

A break from normal service today, as I thought I’d post up a little video of me being silly on stage on the occasion of Science Showoff  a few weeks ago. Science Showoff is a fantastic open-mic night for science communication, organised by the inimitable Steve Cross of UCL. People get up on stage in the back room of a pub in Clerkenwell, and do science-y things for the amusement (and occasionally even for the education) of the crowd.

For their May event, I thought I’d have a go at re-creating the world’s first brain-imaging experiment, live, on-stage, using nothing more than a table, a rolling-pin, and a kitchen scale. How was such a feat accomplished (I hear you gasp, dear reader, in tones hushed with reverential awe)? I shall explain.

Angelo Mosso – 19th Century Italian physiologist and ‘world’s first neuroimager’.

What’s often called ‘the world’s first neuroimaging experiment’ was conducted by a gentleman by the name of Angelo Mosso in the late 19th Century; a professor of physiology at the University of Turin. He’s generally credited with the notion that blood flow in the brain is related to mental activity; he arrived at this conclusion by studying patients with open head wounds – the pulsations of their dura would increase in frequency when the patients became agitated or engaged in some demanding mental task.

He also (apparently) designed an experiment in order to see the effect of increased blood flow during mental activity in ‘normal’, uninjured people. This was the first time an external apparatus had been used to visualise the internal processes of the brain – hence ‘world’s first neuroimaging experiment’. I say ‘apparently’ because the only write-up we have about the experiment is from William James’ journal of 1890:

“The subject to be observed lay on a delicately balanced table which could tip downwards either at the head or the foot if the weight of either end were increased. The moment emotional or intellectual activity began in the subject, down went the balance at the head-end, in consequence of the redistribution of blood in his system…”

Now, most people who’ve written about this experiment since, have generally cast doubt on the idea that this could ever actually work. But, being on occasion an incautious type, and thinking that even if it didn’t work it could at least be amusing, I figured I’d just give it a try. I used a couple of modern-day modifications – I got a cheap digital scale off Amazon, which could distinguish increments of 0.1g, and used a webcam pointed at the scale’s readout to display it to the crowd via a projector. I rested the head-end of the balance-board on the scale, and figured that any increase in blood-flow to the brain should result in an increase in weight on the scale. The able and moderately-willing volunteer for the experiment was my good friend Thom Scott-Phillips of Edinburgh (and Durham) University and the video was shot by Rita Santos. Unfortunately it’s impossible to make out the scale readout on the video, but it definitely worked. Oh yes. Absolutely. *Ahem*. I’m also slightly embarrassed to admit that it contains quite a few of the naughty swears, but, y’know, it’s just that kind of event. If it’s alright for Ben Goldacre, then it’s alright for me, dammit.

Without further ado then – the video (watch it on YouTube for glorious 720p):

Enjoy! TTFN.


About Matt Wall

I do brains. BRAINZZZZ.

Posted on May 23, 2012, in Commentary, Experimental techniques, Neuroimaging and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 8 Comments.

  1. This is pretty freakin awesome.

  2. nice work, am wondering about an outreach activity (minus the swearing and cock references :o) based around this, might work

  3. Im very much a hands on advocate (O run a “Blue Peter Psychology’ fro the NSLC for teachers) and I (rather oddly) am not all that bothered if things don’t work quote as well as they might, its the approach that excites (see what i did there) me !

    PS where you at VSS ?

    • True – the point is to illustrate a principle really.

      No – didn’t make it to VSS – haven’t done any vision work for a couple of years really – I’m a pain/drugs person now! Will be at SFN in October though…

  4. you missed out portable Beuchet Chair demo – check facebook.com/viperlib for some photos from VSS – chaos (and hence poorly aligned) but fun.

    Good luck on the pain/drugs – good from ‘Impact’ !

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: